Fictional demonstration — invented competition, organizer and quotations. Not a real document.
Sample reports
Three fictional competitions
Invented names, organizers and quotations show how CRIT reports strong conditions, mixed conditions, and substantial concerns with missing information. None of these documents exist.
Strong documented conditions
Halden Bay Harbour Reading Room
Municipality of Halden Bay (fictional)
90
Open reportEvidence coverage15/15 criteria · 100%Mixed documented conditions
Riverside Market Hall Renewal
Corvel Urban Development Trust (fictional)
56
Open reportEvidence coverage13/15 criteria · 87%Substantial concerns and missing information
Skyline Cultural Landmark Ideas Prize
Aurex Global Events Ltd (fictional)
Insufficient evidence
Open reportEvidence coverage8/15 criteria · 53%
Compare the samples
The same comparison is available for your own completed reports.
These reports use different currencies (EUR, GBP, USD). Amounts are shown as stated and are not converted; do not compare them as equivalent.
| Criterion | Halden Bay Harbour Reading RoomFictional | Riverside Market Hall RenewalFictional | Skyline Cultural Landmark Ideas PrizeFictional |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scores — based on available evidence | |||
| Overall score | 90 Strong documented conditions | 56 Moderate documented conditions | — Insufficient evidence |
| A. Who competes? | 90 | 55 | 13 |
| B. Who decides? | 95 | 63 | — Insufficient evidence |
| C. Who benefits? | 85 | 50 | — Insufficient evidence |
| Evidence coverage | 15/15 · 100% | 13/15 · 87% | 8/15 · 53% |
| Documented conditions | |||
| Eligibility | Registered EEA architects; graduate teams led by a registered architect. Found3/4 | Three public buildings > GBP 5m in 10 years; consortia allowed. Found2/4 | Not stated Not foundUnknown |
| Entry fee | €0 None Found | £0 None Found | US$250 USD 250 (USD 180 early-bird), non-refundable Found |
| Submission requirements | Stage 1: two A1 sheets, 600 words. Stage 2: design development and cost estimate. Found3/4 | 4 A1 boards, 1:200 model, outline cost plan in 7 weeks. Found2/4 | 5 renderings, 90 s animation, structural report, model photos. Found0/4 |
| Compensation | €18,000 EUR 18,000 per stage-two team (5 teams). Found | £3,000 GBP 3,000 per shortlisted team (6 teams). Found | US$0 None Found |
| Jury independence | Independent majority; declarations; related parties excluded. Found4/4 | Conflict declarations; Trust majority. Found2/4 | Not stated Not foundUnknown |
| Anonymity | Coded entries, anonymous until the jury report is signed. Found4/4 | Anonymised review, interviews afterwards. Found3/4 | Not stated Not foundUnknown |
| Publication of evaluation records | Reasoned jury report published online. Found4/4 | Not stated Not foundUnknown | Not stated Not foundUnknown |
| Intellectual property | Copyright retained; credited exhibition and publication. Found3/4 | Perpetual unpaid licence over all submissions. Found1/4 | Full IP assignment to organizer. Found0/4 |
| Public benefit commitments | Residents, schools, harbour workers; two public workshops. Found4/4 | Affordable stalls for traders; covered public space. Found3/4 | Not stated Not foundUnknown |
| Report | |||
| Methodology version | v1.0 | v1.0 | v1.0 |